View from the Green Room: ‘To hell with all strong silent men'
Philadelphia Here I Come was performed at Dunhill Community Hall.
Dunhill Players served up a treat tonight with Brian Friel’s 1964 classic tale of emigration and unspoken love between father and son. Friel addresses the conflict by giving two voices to his anti-hero Gar. One is the taciturn stubbornness of Gar Public (Miceál Casey) and the other is the inner voice of the energetic, loquacious, creative force that is Gar Private (Jonathan Whelan).
Private captures all the monotony of small-town rural Ireland, appropriately called Ballybeg (Baile Beag), as he punctures the mind-numbing routine of Gar’s dull, taciturn father S B O’Donnell (Peter Casey) with litanies that predict his behaviour. SB is a man "who never drinks a second cup of tea" and suffers severe stomach cramps if he leaves Ballybeg. ‘Tethered by the toilet," declares Private, "tragic." SB’s hardware store, that contains only the bare necessities, is the mirror image of a man ruled by routine, hardwired by custom and who treats his 25-year-old son as a boy.
Fascinating characters – either real or imagined – crowd into Gar’s world on the night before he leaves for Philadelphia. Master Boyle (JP Harney) calls in to bid farewell to a pupil who was probably the only child who ever showed him some kindness. Boyle, however, comes with a sackload of bitterness and regret.
A former boyfriend of Gar’s teenage mother, Máire, who died three days after giving birth to him, the master shares love and bitterness from the same cup: "You’ll do well. You’re young, healthy, average intelligence", although not intelligent enough to recognise the mawkishness of Boyle’s recently self-published poems.
Former girlfriend Kate Doogan (Cocomae Milne) also calls but Gar’s temper gets the better of him and the pangs of unrequited love tumble out in hurtful comments that cannot ever be forgotten. He replays his failure to ask for Kate’s hand from her father Senator Doogan (David Walsh), who already has plans for Kate’s future. Daddy Doogan sees no future for his daughter with a shop boy waiting forever to inherit his father’s tiny hardware store and has already lined up a college friend’s doctor-son.
The arrival of ‘The Boys’ – the bully Ned (Johnny Ryan), the obsequious Tom (Martin Harney) and gormless Joe (Jer Casey) – brings great fun to the play with their obvious and empty boasts of sexual conquest and alpha-male daring on the football pitch. Private punctures all their blather with accurate accounts of their supposed daring-do and also reveals the awful future of those who are destined to live out lives of banality and penny-pinching in rural Ireland.
The pivotal arrival of Ben Burton (David Casey), Con Sweeney (Ben Casey) and Aunt Lizzie (Anne Marie Queally) proves to be the turning point in Gar’s life. Lizzie was his mother’s oldest sister and Gar is the only child of the five Gallagher girls and Lizzie is desperate to share their Philadelphia home with him.
Failed IVF treatments and drugs leaves Lizzie reliant on booze and downers to get through this troubled visit. Her accusation that Gar is silent, emotionless and just like SB prompts him to accept Lizzie’s invitation to Philly where a job as a lift-bellhop awaits.
Gar’s only impetuous move leaves him no room to manoeuvre. Canon Mick O’Byrne’s (Michael Hutchinson) nightly visit offers little in the way of intervention and Gar’s treasured memories of fishing on a blue boat on Lough Corrib with his father singing to him are not shared by his father.
Neither Gar nor his father can express their love for each other despite their desperate need to do so. Sadly, it’s left to housekeeper and surrogate mother Madge (Louise Walsh) to interpret the silences… "Just because he doesn't say much doesn't mean that he hasn't feelings like the rest of us."
This is a fine production from Dunhill Players. A large and word-perfect cast, with strong interpretation and firm direction from Bertie Rogers, gave us a night to remember in the Dunhill Community Hall. This is what amateur acting is all about.


