Deemed disposal ‘too high’ and ‘posing challenge’ for Irish investors – Harris

By Grainne Ni Aodha, Press Association

Deemed disposal is “too high” and “posing a real challenge” for Irish investors, Finance Minister Simon Harris has said.

He was speaking at the Central Bank of Ireland, as 300 people gathered for a savings and investment forum that Harris hoped would be held every year.

The forum was to discuss a savings and investment account (SIA) that Harris has proposed.

Harris has said in recent weeks that Irish citizens are the best savers in the EU, with around €170 billion set aside, but are not getting a good return on their savings due to a lack of an investment culture.

The Tánaiste said he wanted the SIA to be legislated for in the next budget and made available next year.

The account would need to offer a “simple” single rate of tax each year to be attractive to people, he said.

He also said the deemed disposal rule, which is applied to investments in Irish funds and life assurance products, is “too high”.

He said his predecessor and party colleague Paschal Donohoe had lowered the rate in the last budget.

“I believe it’s too high. It went from 41 per cent to 38 per cent,” he told reporters at the Central Bank on Tuesday morning.

“I actually believe the issue is broader than the rate, being honest. I believe it’s actually the policy rationale.

“It was brought in at a certain time when the landscape of investment in Ireland was very different. And I think the actual policy rationale more broadly is as big an issue.”

Despite people doing the right thing, that's not earning any money, and it'll be worth less to those grandkids when they go to withdraw it than it is when they put it in. That's what we're trying to fix here

He added: “The pace at which we can move on all of these things in one budget will obviously be a matter for overall discussion across Government.

“But I do think the Deemed Disposal issue is posing a real challenge for Irish investors, and I do think the policy rationale for it now is questionable at best and I would like to see further progress made on it.”

He said that the Government needed to ensure there was a tax system in Ireland “that is helping people who are trying to build up their own economic resilience”.

“Irish people are doing their very best to put away small amounts of money on a regular basis.

“I was in a credit union in Cork recently, I met a woman called Mary who goes into the credit union in Cork every Friday and puts a fiver in for each of her five grandkids’ credit union accounts every week.

“And she’s going to keep on doing that, and she wants to build up a little nest egg for them.

“There are examples of grannies, parents, individuals doing that right across the country.

“But at the moment, despite people doing the right thing, that’s not earning any money, and it’ll be worth less to those grandkids when they go to withdraw it than it is when they put it in. That’s what we’re trying to fix here.

“If we’re actually to build up true economic resilience, we’ve got to help middle Ireland build it up themselves.”